Soviet Style Economics Was Insane and Here’s Why

Video quality	The size	Download

Information Soviet Style Economics Was Insane and Here’s Why

Title	:	Soviet Style Economics Was Insane and Here’s Why
Lasting	:	25.12
Date of publication	:
Views	:	2,3 jt

I thought you would have like 2 million subscribers until I looked at the number and realised you only had around 120 I hope you get more subscribes because you have very good content
Comment from : RetroMedia

I don’t buy the portion about lack of innovation They had plenty Put the first man in space Great video nonetheless
Comment from : Koskism

Thought this was a semi decent video until 16:00 when it just turns into clear anti-communist/pro-capitalist propaganda
Comment from : Damage

As my great grandfather in maoist china once said “I work I get 5, I don’t work I get 5 Why work?”
Comment from : PiethagorasTearem

People say that the communism make the employee work less, I think they where talking about capitalism😂
Comment from : KukaBeludo

Was extractitice on purpose? 😅
Comment from : Nikhil Raktale

Slave labour and central direction in commodity production will show results with sufficient resources and labor
Comment from : philip dias

I thought this upload on 1 april?
Comment from : SimpleA²

When did WW1 end in 1917 ????
Comment from : Julien Genetti

It's funny how the pro russian internet trolls are somehow not present in the comment section here :)
Comment from : Momchil Andonov

Don't worry guys, it wasn't really communism We'll get there next time, only a few hundred million more lives and we'll arrive at Utopia
Comment from : The Nathanimal

exactly in china
Comment from : Qian Sucheng

China been playing with their own crap all their lives Making viruses after virus Come to think about it that is all China is really know for is playing with doo doo
Comment from : Rekt_ philosopher_Sigma00

The 1920's was filled with Bonnie and Clide running around and baby face Nelson blasted those coppersAl Capone was mad someone stole his whiskey and set up a coup When Chicago Mob first came into the world Offering protection
Comment from : Rekt_ philosopher_Sigma00

10:05 1914
Comment from : Crisis Moon

0:18 ERM ACTUALLY 1918!
Comment from : Crisis Moon

This vídeo is plaged with half truths and historical and political inaccuracies It is clear that the knowledge shown about the Soviet system is superficial and based on hoaxes and Western propaganda
Comment from : Alejandro Perea

The problem with capitalism is that it does not care for human needs, but human desiresbrbrThe problem with communism is that it doesn't allow for human free will and takes away spirituality and religion
Comment from : Isaac Kassis

The general joke in the Eastern Block was "We pretend to work, they pretend to pay us"
Comment from : ComputationalEnigma

I’ve been homeless & hungry most of my life… yay capitalism 🎉
Comment from : Psivil Disobedience

There is a saying in PolandbrWhat dosen't glow and dosen't fit in an ass?brA soviet tool to glow in an ass
Comment from : Mister Potato

long live Marxism-Leninism Long live the great Russian revolution
Comment from : Shattik Bandyopadhyaa

How the 1920s Russian economy arose brGoes back 500 years
Comment from : Michael Harris

just in case communists think this is proof that communism is better the country thrived not the people when the people never had freedom or any possesions all production can just goes to the collective (the dictator)
Comment from : Charlie Tapp

ww1 ended in 1918 not 17
Comment from : Asepsis

So insane that it defeated the 3rd Reich that had the whole of Europe under occupation
Comment from : jose raul miguens

That video has some points But it looks like that destruction and occupation of 40 of industrialized territory during WWII played no role in Soviet economy
Comment from : ksotar

70 yrats later you canr find a thing in shops…what a miricale…
Comment from : אייל שניידר

broo forgot about slavery, colonialism and war profiteering as factors for US growth
Comment from : zohravar

Yhea 0 unenployment, its a wonder what u can do with slave labor😂
Comment from : Sebastian Tuscano

WWI ended in 1918
Comment from : Pommel

I do like how you researched this but I really feel like you should have included the Orthodox/Catholic split Orthodox Christianity with its emphasis on Caesaropapism really ties into how centralized the Russian state was leading up to the rise of the soviet system When the main religion of the masses also serves as a state institution that creates a serious cultural divide Consider in the west how the early middle ages were rampant with political squabbling between the Catholic Church and European aristocracy which acted as a bizarre check against complete authoritarianism meanwhile in russia, i the head of the church disagreed with the Tsarhe died
Comment from : GreyKnight343

bro please bro, we have to try it just one more time bro please itll work this time i promise bro please
Comment from : Adrian Krasniqi

Thanos was right all along Snapping half of thr Europe population basically boosted everyone standard of living
Comment from : chief

Video was good until 13:41
Comment from : Alistair The Great

Clickbait title
Comment from : Bumarang Nebula 2

"with the end of the world war in 1917" lol
Comment from : tortoise flipper

He said WW1 ended in 1917 should I keep watching?
Comment from : Nicholas Pollard

I love the map on 15:09 of 'Germans invading' eastern Europe - if you looked at pre-1940 regional borders, it would become clear that Soviets collaborated with Nazis in dividing the region between themselves
Comment from : Lukas R

There were Americans moving to Russia for employment
Comment from : Wayne Stewart

"The defeater of capitalism" the US & UK fought on 4/5 fronts during WWII Soviets fought on oneand undoubtedly would've lost if Hitler didn't divert troops to the Caucus region, waste resources bombing England, declare war on the US, etc I could name a dozen more reasons brbrWhat is it with young people thinking the Soviets won WWII by themselves?
Comment from : Boba Fett

Where's the photo from 15:28 from??
Comment from : JoDrizzly

"Capitalist innovation" look at the last 8 years of iphone brother
Comment from : delsbf777

I like how you conveniently skipped over the fact that Tzar Nicolas II and his entire family were executed by Bolsheviks while in exilebrbrLenin died four years after a failed assassination attempt by Fanny Kaplan on August 30, 1918 (it is believed she was not acting alone) A complicated surgery was performed (in 1922) in order to extract a bullet that was lodged in Lenin’s neck Upon the completion of the surgery Lenin’s health deteriorated drastically and he lost control of the right side of his body He died as the result of those complications on January 21, 1924 brbrYou also forgot to mention the process of “dekulakization” of so called “very unproductive farmers” as you put it When in reality they were extremely productive and knowledgeable Their land was stripped away and entire families were imprisoned Government took all their land and personal possessions Inexperienced managers replaced those farmers under direct supervision of Trofim Denisovich Lysenko, a Soviet agronomist As the result, millions of Soviet people died of starvation in the 1930s including 6,000,000 Ukrainians brbrSpeaking of prisons and the main reason Stalin managed to generate such enormous wealth in such short period of time was the enslavement of millions of Russian people and the expansion of GULAG system that was originally started by none other than Lenin himself Nazis took that idea a step further by creating extermination camps The world looked away as tens of millions of Russian people continued to die inside the Soviet work camps until 1960s
Comment from : pavel0900

More like casual speller extractatice, surfdom, powerfull Yikes
Comment from : Cullen Heater

There's only one reason to speak against comunism; FASCISM This channel is clearly fascist
Comment from : Soak Puppet Account

Animal Farm indeedand now the idiot traitorous socialists in this country are pushing us into oblivion
Comment from : Dewayne Condra

The incentive problem of communist society is not the only problem: see "the economic calculation problem"brCommunist economy are simply impossible at a much deeper level
Comment from : anteeko

I know c and v are next to each other, but surely you can read?
Comment from : Curb Your Shi*

He thinks western revolutions were from a "broad coalition" 🤣🤣🤣brbrUnless of course you were female, black, native, catholic or protestant, hated Robespierre, loved Robespierre and many other "small" details 🤣🤣🤣brbrWestern ass must taste like chocolate since this guy loves kissing it
Comment from : Kars Ram

Well, now both countries just have oligarchs that own the government with huge inequality and worker exploitation Looks like Marx was still right about the criticisms of capitalism
Comment from : Ragged Flaggon

Is the author of this youtube video fcking retarded? Germany was the most thriving country
Comment from : John Smith

Hehe so much anti communist propaganda In the first time I thought Ok this boy may know something about socialist economy and talk about that but later “12 MILLION PEOPLE DIED” d
Comment from : IDeniz Bal

Only Gulag works in Socialism
Comment from : Nikolay Помещенко

did bro just say ww1 ended in 1917
Comment from : Ashu- that idiot

Motherdruckers in my 76 in Siberia my Dick works best because I fkedd off cities, technology and civilization So what you about? About dying with diabetes, insults, coronary diseases, mad psyche, autocatastrophies, train's crushes, plain's falling, cancer - that'$ the value of your technology and working harder and longer, stupid gosh
Comment from : Остров Рокочэт Смерть сосным нацистам

Pile of rubbish
Comment from : Bogdan Amidzic

"Collectivization directly lead to the death of 12 million people "brEverybody gangsta, until western "historians" start to calculate, how many people have been eaten by "bloody Stalin") brSeriosly, what is it? Where is this information from? It's looks like another cold war propaganda fake, or information from the Soviet dissident movement I don't now, which of this worsebr(I'm from Russia, and even there, with our very anticommunist government, suddenly for western readers, I haven't heard such a number EVEN IN UKRAINE there are NO SUCH HISTORIANS that aprove this number, I swear)
Comment from : Артемий

12:02 that is inaccurate, Carl Marx was in favour of reformation He classified labour moments in three categories: 1) Economic guide movement: for example, the workers striking to a factory owner to improve their works conditions with their employer 2) Political reformist: the workers crating a political movement to defend their rights, with the last objective of the abolishment of private property 3) Revolutionary change: create a worker’s state that end with capitalism Marx Criticise the first because their wins are temporary in all sense, however, recognise that economic guided movement have the potential to became political moment (reformist or revolutionary) The critic that made to Reformism is that make capitalism more tolerable and discourages long term political changes as the workers do not realize the structural injustice of the economic system; that is why Marx prefer revolution, but it is not against reformism
Comment from : santiago Alcantara

8:20 you just wrote off a fundamental deviation of human thinking, as some would argue in the wrong direction, as “fair laws and intellectual property” I get not everyone is a leftist but I think this specifically is key to at least accurately represent capital and private vs personal property and build fair understanding of the two systems of social exchange
Comment from : GRAYSCAL3

We still have an extractive system where things are absolutely imortally reinforced by a liberal system of deep state and capital Industry assuredly falls to overproduction and undervaluation of labor that crashes economies like clockwork that has to be corrected by indirect government subsidy or regulation should the stars and planets align with the ancient winds of the warp Less overt maybe, but capitalism is so much more stable that the extraction is equally as oppressive
Comment from : GRAYSCAL3

0:15 umm what were the 20s defined as? It was a thinly gilded/dark age for a reason…
Comment from : GRAYSCAL3

Very good video
Comment from : Blazer boi

Capitalism is the worst
Comment from : Noah Philippe Lavallee

Most of that technology and space race accomplishments were do to how many German scientists they captured
Comment from : Reese Jabs

Marx was not German, he was Jewish
Comment from : lookoutforchris

Karl Marx wasn't really of Germanic stock now was he? Probably wrong to refer to him as "German"
Comment from : DixieFatline

You don't mistake about Hispanic is not same Mexicans
Comment from : José Salvador Roqueni

western propaganda east shit read a book on theory total shit
Comment from : Unknown

Funny how the communists just did the opposite of what was working in the west They overthrew a government based on serfdom to create a government based on industrial serfdom
Comment from : Ha Ha

Song on 130?
Comment from : Ivan Lesca

Só, in the "problems with soviet economy" chapter you basically try to sell the argument that USSR sucks because they hired twice as many people to perform the same that was performed in America and innovation was not used to enhance profit the most?brSo, would you rather have 100 people working 6 hours a day and production focused on just being enough or 50 people working 10-12 hours, being stretched to their limit, making barely enough money to feed themselves, but overpeoducing not for them but for the company owner while the other 50 are working informally or just plain unemployed begging at the streets?brbrI mean, fan or hater?
Comment from : Davih Rodrigues

You sound like Stalin would come up with the 5-year plan out of his head in a tyranic way, which is just not true and there is lots of evidence to that It was crafted and subjected to the party scrutiny by the process of democratic centralism This video sure has its moments and started really good, but after that just sounded like empty anti-comunist propaganda That's sad
Comment from : Davih Rodrigues

they NEVER had nuclear superioritybrthat's the lie of the American MIC To get a bigger budget
Comment from : rodan one

Every economic systems in itself have flaws doesnt matter which one Depends on who you're your opinion and bias would side or against which one of them At the end, the life itself and how we should sustain it is pretty much absurd
Comment from : Lukas Wilhelm

Sounds like life in Canada fee employment options and stuck in one shit place forever Welcome to life under the elected Lords!
Comment from : Dean Unterreiner

Going from a sod house to a wooden one with plates isn't that impressive
Comment from : Dean Unterreiner

Wwi ended in 1918 Hmm Not a good start
Comment from : KKupsky

The First World War ended in 1917? Lol learn history bro
Comment from : Kuba Tomyślak

Russia was always good at doing things in laboratory and chemistry labUS and europe always better at industrial innovation
Comment from : subodhgautam649

Helped that they looted Eastern Europe, managed to stay afloat a good fourty years
Comment from : drkinferno72

Lol” zero unemployment “😂
Comment from : miss me

Here in Cuba all people under a title get paid the same, it doesn't matter if u work more or less, u'll get paid the same as the fellow who works 20 times harder than u brThis is part of the Socialism/Communism economy, and that's what happens when all the power of a country is concentred in hands of few people(state "workers")brDunno if I made me understand (Im not well versed in the english language 😅)
Comment from : Kuro Allen