Title | : | How To Master Any Language: Comprehensible Input |
Lasting | : | 6.34 |
Date of publication | : | |
Views | : | 73 rb |
|
it’s just bullsh*it! u have to memorize words and grammar and practice speaking and listening ! Comment from : anitamezym |
|
Wow You have described EXACTLY what I have been doing, and yes, it is the right way In particular, I have watched Children's films with the (same language) subtitles on, so that I can compare what I hear in my new language with how it looks in text Comment from : adnalm |
|
@2:23 "But I really biwants/i/b to emphasize" What dialect of [North American] English is that?br*Every second you spend in a dictionary is one second of information-overload, one that will destabilize and derail your core attention, simply because of the attention demanded by doing a dictionary look-up, compounded by all the options for redirection, new information, and distraction it provides It is the quintessential "going down a rabbit hole" Comment from : Eduard Qualls |
|
very good❤❤❤ Comment from : CintaMusikOfficial |
|
Great video and I've just reached the point where I get this But, I have to ask about the hat Comment from : Darryl Brooks |
|
I do not see which video to watch at the end brThat one, you recommend watchingbrPlease put the link in the description Thank you Comment from : Thomas Schroeder |
|
An addition to your method is to learn common words and basics such as sentence construction and grammer After doing that a lot of input will be comprehensible from that language I think you're too into "we only learn through comprehensible input" and you're biased in this video Nothing wrong with learning 1000+ most common words and grammer so input can be much more comprehensible The problem with traditional learning is we learn the basics but it isn't really applied anywhere so we tend to forget everything Our brain needs to associate what we learn to some relevance otherwise it'll forget it Comment from : EngA |
|
Only if education policy makers would comprehend this! Comment from : Ozgur Karatas |
|
Where can I find that man’s lecture Comment from : Zain Sobh |
|
Wow! Never heard of it before Great tip, thank u so much! Comment from : Büşra |
|
This is about the same idea of the inductive contextual method of Hans Orberg, used in his Lingua Latina Per Se Illustrata (LLPSI) Comment from : Rodrigo Fernández |
|
The first word revealed from the Quran was "READ" So read it ❤ Comment from : Douae Elhajoui |
|
I disagree, traditional method is the best, mingle the four, reading, listening, writing and speaking with lot of different practice, I wish if there is a better easier way though Comment from : L |
|
Everyone preaches about comprehensible input, but there's hardly any material out there for most languages Hardly any adult has time to really learn a language, anyway Language acquisition is sold like weight loss Comment from : some guy |
|
That's stupid You will make thousands of mistakes if you don't learn the grammar of classical languages: especially arabic, latina, and Sanskrit Without grammar, your tongue is disabled; your reading—pig headed You can't understand the multi-faceted way of understanding words and sentences Comment from : Abdul Basit ibn Adam—The Logician |
|
I think one very important thing to consider is: iavoid the written word/i as much as possible in the beginning (for a long while) The reason is that the written word will absolutely iruin/i your pronunciation as you'll invariably try to pronounce the words in your native language way That's where all the atrocious "z" pronounced the English way in German comes from, etc etc Children learn to speak only by ear, remember that Comment from : JanPBtest |
|
This is very interesting - I think I started to learn English by watching Muzzy In Gondoland when I was a little kid It really helped me learn basic words without any effort and after that, I used movies and games to learn basic English Comment from : Pedro Miranda |
|
Well, Doctor Whateverhisnameis has probably acquired German but he should have learnt it too as he makes a massive declination mistake after only two very basic sentences, not to mention his accent which is by far the weirdest I've ever encountered 😂 Comment from : Hugo Tolpi |
|
So basically this is how everyone learned their first language, its gotta be the best way Comment from : F D |
|
video starts at 2:10 Comment from : vaboomadeit |
|
Keep reading linguistics Krashen is most definitely NOT “well respected “ among his peers Comment from : John Bocskay |
|
Does anybody have any tips for comprehensible input for Chinese? I’d love to read something, but I also think that I won’t be able to read a lot Comment from : Simon Yakovlev |
|
Booooooom!!! Such a great explanation! Thank you Comment from : Avery Wight |
|
How many languages have you acquired so far? Comment from : Андрей Першин |
|
When you are on beginner level, there is only one way to understand messages - is to translate So, school method perfectly works for beginners and intermediate learners, because they can understand if you live in non-english-speaking country there is no chance to create effective english bubble, that's why old-school techiques of memorizing words and grammer might be the best and only way to build foundation for further aquiring Comment from : Андрей Першин |
|
I like English, french, Germán, italian, portuguese, and spanish Comment from : Juan Hernandez |
|
Kaboh Comment from : Juan Hernandez |
|
Balshoe spashiba Comment from : Juan Hernandez |
|
Namasté Comment from : Juan Hernandez |
|
Greetingns from México Comment from : Juan Hernandez |
|
One interesting observation of mine is that the reason why speaking improve your language skill even though you only acquire language through input is that when you are talking, you are in an environment where you can manipulate the input in such a way that you can decipher and it also contain a large amount of information which result in both improving the quality and quantity of the input Comment from : 2WR |
|
Brains are not what you are concerned with when you acquire a language, it is your mind Brains are just an organ like your heart or liver Minds comprehend and acquire Comment from : Patrick See |
|
Great video I realised watching this that you don't understand a new sport by learning the rules, you learn it by acquiring it, by watching the sport and learning the rules in context with the input Comment from : Cliff Jones |
|
To acquire a second or third language requires motivation This works for learning a language too But, as this video believes, it is better to want to acquire a language because the understandable messages should not be boring I acquired Spanish because at age 14 I was taken to a corrida by my dad and I wanted to understand it more I ended up buying books about toros Now I have the nerve to speak the language in Spain Secondly, I taught history and I had an interest in pre- and post-WWII Germany So, as a student I visited the Deutsche Demokratische Republik where I picked up my very first words from a border policeman "Ihren Reisepass, bitte Wo ist Ihr Visum?" Eventually I was making sentences which I had never heard! I do not know where I got the nerve to raise my voice to a Berlin policeman who did not want to bother with me "Ich möchte Hilfe!" Where did that come from? Is it even correct? Straight away a different policeman got up from his desk and brought me to the right place Imagine I gave an order to a policeman in Berlin using German I was acquiring the language! Comment from : Jean |
|
Now i can't understand all, o maybe nothing, but i like this way, learn, listening and reading, full input because i love the english languagebrbrSorry for my write i don't use translate with this, i'm spanish native Comment from : Xbolu16 |
|
I never made so much progress in English than those last 4 years, listening to content on YouTube in English with no subtitles brI struggled a lot at first but as I only watched content I liked, it was interesting and I acquired the language brbrNow I can even understand words or expressions I never heard before Comment from : Azeltix |
|
Very well sir, thank you👍 Comment from : J B |
|
is that LED lights of some kind in your cap ? what's up with that? Comment from : Alex in the sky |
|
But what if I aquire the knowledge to learn them Comment from : Average Joe Karate |
|
I am an English language teacherbrI basically tell any parents that seek my help to teach their kids that we are not dealing with a school subject, we are dealing with a language, and the difference is huge I also tell them that I can teach it as both a language and a subject, but the latter is just for tests, and they will not acquire a language from it at all Comment from : ZGoodTerrorist |
|
It's literally the only way babies learn their mother tongue No native speaker even thinks about grammar consciously Comment from : M |
|
Dude, is that a hat with a camera in the brim? Comment from : soulpa7ch |
|
I tried hundreds of times to learn a second language and nothing clicked for years until finally one day I understood that there's a difference between studying something and knowing something Studying is hard and the effort can get in the way of yourself being able to acquire it through having fun and just saying "Ooh, I know this one easy" Study, be patient and don't stress You can do it! Comment from : Taylor Diamond |
|
Wow So that’s how I learned to speak Spanish? I didn’t know there was a name for it I thought I was just immersing myself in the language I’m about 85 fluent, I can read Harry Potter in Spanish but further progress is difficult How do I jump that last 15 to complete fluency? Comment from : Patrick Crain |
|
Why do grown men want to read Harry Potter Comment from : Liam Byrne |
|
Thanks so much Comment from : John Blue: Snake & Turtle Qigong |
|
Sounds like a good approach but I'll not be convinced without triangulated scientific papers showing the efficacy of the comprehensible input approach and it limitationsbrbrListening to the advocacy and testimonials of its creator, or his followers doesn't cut it for me Comment from : David Brisbane |
|
I could teach mathematically illiterate people to comprehend elementary mathematics reasonably easily using drawings and simple diagrams using simple language, but it is very unlikely that without a deep study of maths, that they will ever understand abstract algebra or topologybrbrSo it is with comprehensible input You'd have to wait forever using this approach to attempt a Phd in philosophy in a second language Comment from : David Brisbane |
|
It's just too good to believe You can learn a second language without reading a single grammar book! Comment from : David Brisbane |
|
I wonder how this could be applied to learn other things If anyone could point me to some research, please comment I feel like we are completely ignoring the power of our subconscious mind Comment from : Sam |
|
You are wonder!ful! Comment from : Светлана Паршукова |
|
When I saw your channel name is "fingtam" lol! (I'm sure u know it already that it means "I farted" in Hungarian) Comment from : Andris GameDev |
|
Thank so much! 🙏 Comment from : tonimikael |
|
Dr Pius Ozigbe is Always on time compassionate Empathetic easy to take to and relates exceptionally well Hands down the most effective and efficient doctor I recommend him thank you doctor❤❤ Comment from : BONIFACE THOMAS |
|
I feel this makes sence as when I'm LEARNING a language i feel like im on the out side of it if that makes sense its like a code im constantly cracking, it dont feel natural My only issue is where do you find the content for japanese Comment from : Ash Morris |
|
Hello dear professor brWhat you present is really interesting and crucial,i do appreciate your job,i wish you peace and happiness under the sky of prosperity,all the best,brtake care and have a good time brYour Student from Algeria Comment from : Chemla |
|
I am learning Thai too (-: Comment from : Elliot Maze |
|
Krashan is year's behind every Indian grandma who figured this out centuries ago Comment from : Jason James |
|
Excellent strategy to acquire language Trying to do this with my current attempt at picking up Italian Working great so far! Comment from : Brad Gorman |
|
Good video🎉 Comment from : Ernesto Robles |
|
I love the French YouTube videos of Alice Ayel I wish I could find a video series for learning Modetn Greek using the same technique Alice uses The content on LingQ is good but I like the way Alice uses drawing and gestures She is awesome Comment from : Kevin Jones |
|
I am a British English speaker, looking for a French native speaker to exchange with Comment if you want to exchange Comment from : Jon |
|
Hello, I just published a book: HOW TO ACQUIRE ANY LANGUAGE Is it possible to send you a free copy and have you review it? Comment from : LinuxHurts |
|
That is BSsorry for the word! I've been teaching English for more than 30 years, and it's been proven that it does not work ((( he is NOT the first one who offers that bsold methods work This one is good for A0 and A1sometimesmaybefor A2Just stop listening to such crap , get you books, and study! Comment from : Elena Kondrakova |
|
I did a video series #opetp to give anyone who's doubting all this a personal experience in the shortest possible time Subconscious acquisition is real! Comment from : jan Telakoman |
|
Kind of mean to say, because it's a great video, but this guy's English is off Comment from : nicholas schroeder |
|
I can 100 say that I accedently learnt english, sorry guys Comment from : Abul Amad |
|
Thank you! This will help me a lot Comment from : ijskoude |
|
Thanks :)) Comment from : Yasser Fathelbab |
|
Well, whatever he might have come up with apparently, it completely failed his environment 1 in 5 people, as of the date of this posting, cannot READ or WRITE in Southern California Like I´ve said, all these geniuses from a monolinguist culture are just making money on stupid people Comment from : Espartaco |
|
"Every second you spend in a dictionary is one second less of comprehensible input" brbrNot if you're using a monolingual dictionary, which itself will be a source of comprehensible input Comment from : Steve Smith |
|
Highly recommend using pimsleur Comment from : reluctantbeeswax |
|
In other words, sacrifice the novels/games you are really interested in getting into for that sweet sweet input but get the downside of ruining your first experience Comment from : KnightCrown |
|
Man please,I'd like to now more about you are talking about, but my inglesh is not very goodbrbrI'd like to see you talking this video in PortuguesebrbrEu já tinha visto algo relacionado ao input no canal Mairo Vergara e fiquei curiosobrbrEu sou BRASILEIRO Comment from : Robert Oliveira |
|
Could u pease tell what's the mic you're using Comment from : Abderahim |
|
What about speaking? Comment from : Petar Petrovic |
|
I’m at the beginning of my goal to learn Spanish so I found Yoga flows on YouTube by Spanish speaking teachers It’s helping a lot with my comprehension Plus, I signed up for Spotify to get access to popular Latin music in my favorite genre Fingers crossed for success Comment from : hunnerdayEDT |
|
I got this idea somewhat vaguely on my own, because I like to write and even my native language I improve in by writing and finding new words to describe something So I decided to write a little in the language I was learning, simple stories until I could get more and more descriptive This is something I think creative people can find fun, because it makes learning more natural and you have an associated scene to remember the vocabulary with Comment from : kovici |
|
Easier said than done Comment from : Ayako Saito |
|
Abosolutely true, now I'm convinced reading and listening are the keys to succeed when it comes to learning a new language In the past I feel hopeless when I wanted to speak or even write, but now I able to get my ideas across and all of that happened because I read and listen a lot I still use some books for English learner when I have encountered somthing I don't understand but I spend most of the fime just for reading and listening In my opion the best method may differ from person to person But in the end if someone wants to speak a target language fluently they have to somehow gain a lot of input, I have never met anyone who can speak a language well if they don't gain a lot of input On the other hand, if you don't gain a lot of input you are likely to ask yourself like how can I stop translating in my head You should understand interviews, presentations, With ease before you think about speaking fluently In my opinion what you produce is just a reflection of your input, there is no way around it Comment from : Kim Cường Trần |
|
Yes, yes, yes Comment from : Paul Hogan |
|
this is how i learned english without knowing this is the most effective way i used to watch english youtube and everything i did on a pc was in english so yeah and its not my first language Comment from : Algirdas LTU |
|
I look at every single word in the dictionary and it is helpful Slow though but understanding the content is important for me Comment from : Vinit |
|
Comprehensible input must be hard if you’re blind Comment from : Handicappuccino music |
|
You deserve a billion likes What a great vid ! Comment from : Jessie |
|
My mom lived in Mexico for two years When she came back, she was fluent in Spanish, right down to her accent matched that of the locality she was in I know this, because as a teenager in Indiana, I saw her help some Mexicans who were looking for masa in the grocery store (but didn't know where to look) She told them what aisle, and one of them said, "Where in Mexico did you say you're from?" So, this comprehensible method works, for sure Comment from : BlackSeranna |
|
wow is very good thank is very interesting Now reading and listening every day for 10 or 15 hours to the day is very good Comment from : Elizabeth |
|
I never learned English in my entire life, when I was a kid I used to watch movies and TV shows with subtitles, and played a lot of video games in English, such as GTA SA, God of War, God Hand and used to listen to a lot of music in English, used to go and search for lyrics and try to sing even though I didn't understand anything they said, but still I did it anyway, but the impressive part about this (at least for me) is learning English was never something I wanted to do, it just came naturally, and as time goes by (doing these things) I was able to understand and speak English, which comes to the point of making this comment if you wanna learn a language (any language) make it a fun and an entertaining experience, because when you combine fun and learning it becomes more affective Comment from : itachi uchiha |
Comprehensible Input: How To Make Input MORE COMPREHENSIBLE In Language Learning РѕС‚ : Robin MacPherson Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
What Is Comprehensible Input? РѕС‚ : Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
How To Type In Urdu Language Without Any Experience | Google Input Tools | Urdu - Hindi РѕС‚ : Tech Ki Baatein Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
Value | Take the View-Master VR Challenge | View-Master Challenge | View-Master РѕС‚ : ViewMaster Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
Input Based Language Learning, a Powerful Snowball РѕС‚ : Steve Kaufmann - lingosteve Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
Is input more important than output in language learning? РѕС‚ : Phoenix Hou Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
The myth of input | How NOT to learn a language РѕС‚ : Canguro English Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
Translate any PDF book to any language|how to translate book,dox,ppt|2022| РѕС‚ : Smart Tech in Kannada Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
Best Language learning APP | Best App to Learn any Language | Flash Academy | Telugu РѕС‚ : OSD Tech Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |
How to learn any language by yourself- Language tips from a polyglot РѕС‚ : Ruri Ohama Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time |