Home page

Iain McGilchrist u0026 Sharon Dirckx • Brain science, consciousness u0026 God

Frames Iain McGilchrist u0026 Sharon Dirckx • Brain science, consciousness u0026 God

Description Iain McGilchrist u0026 Sharon Dirckx • Brain science, consciousness u0026 God

Comments Iain McGilchrist u0026 Sharon Dirckx • Brain science, consciousness u0026 God

We hope you enjoy the show! To watch the audience Q&A, and to keep updated on the latest episodes, sign up to our newsletter at: wwwthebigconversationshow/ Comment from : @PremierUnbelievable

Sharon Dirckx is completely deluded- fantasy run amok! Comment from : @rollingmancave4547

Your survey link is not working I have answers to all the unanswered questions that are discussed in this talk Please let me know how to contact you and the guests in this video Comment from : @Bharat_Varsh1

Iian has some real gaps in his knowledge tbh Stop giving credence to the nonsense of "there is a difference between mind and brain"brUnscientific claptrap Comment from : @alexnorth3393

the Apostle Paul to Iian McGilchrist: ‘To this unknown god you speak about that is behind many religionsWhat therefore you worship as unknown, this I proclaim to you is the God of the Bible who is known only though Jesus Christ who died and rose from the dead” Comment from : @donmcallister4382

The Special Pleading of Miracles - Every Christian will deny the miracles claimed on behalf of other gods but all miracles are the suspension of the laws of nature & always in your favour Comment from : @realLsf

56:23 It hasn’t gone unnoticed that miraculous cures only occur for diseases that can remiss naturally whilst amputees never miraculously regrow severed limbs 🤔 Comment from : @realLsf

❤❤ Comment from : @VenusLover17

I’ve watched this 3, 4 times Absolutely wonderful! Comment from : @oscarfuentes3982

What a beautiful Sunday song, of listening to this one again and stopping for several hours with reverence and respect who all listens to these lectures of Dr Iian McGilchrist's books 📚 br🙏❤️🌎🕊🎶🎵 Comment from : @cheri238

Do whatever research and study, youwont find more than the upanishad Its matter of insight and knowledge by the perception as result of higher level of consciousness the seers of the east had to know the reality Comment from : @opparashar

The brilliance of Iain is, after watching countless lectures and reading all his hooks, he is always consistent, he never oversteps the limit of his knowledge, and never claims anything that is unsupported by science or reason He quotes from a huge variety of historical philosophers scientists and religious figures He makes intuitive leaps, but always qualifies it with “in my experience” This makes him an extremely compelling person to listen to Comment from : @We_Are_One_Official

Quote; ∆ェis actually in a large part ∀s,artificial stupidity(paraphraised) Comment from : @andromadaus

Not a single original thought Comment from : @Loddfafnisodr

YES! Comment from : @marthadaffue3430

YES! Comment from : @marthadaffue3430

I will short cut you to "the truth" br" Being" is the reason for existence - reverse this and there is the question Comment from : @elizabethwinsor5140

🌷Interesting and cordial exchange🌷 Comment from : @chekideh

Sharon made so much sense and was so patient :) Comment from : @talithakoum1266

I'm always surprised by the wisdom and insight that dreams can provide and that seems to illustrate his point well Comment from : @geralldus

Only when we accept truth as to where we are will we return to order and divine nature Kingdom of GOD in which we are is as foretold Comment from : @societytheclown3117

Wow! Comment from : @sbobkim

This was very interesting But I could say that it is this intellectualising which is, in a sense, keeping us from God or from 'being' I think that Sharon has too much of a theistic dogmatic view I want to hear her definition of "Love" This is word which many people like to use, but which, apparently, no one understands Comment from : @cynic150

Very much enlightening interview Thanks to both McGilchrist and Sharon Comment from : @williamjayaraj2244

Fell O ship Comment from : @paulfredrick6429

Hallow Comment from : @paulfredrick6429

Americans beware giving this group your email address as I did during signup You will not have access to the extra content, all of which shows as blocked on the site Bait and switch without even an email address to contact someone Comment from : @DMK195601

All life is about is identifying your God particle and threading life in healthy synchrony with God Comment from : @jerrymoffatt1530

Very short sighted from the lady, still worth scouring for - Thoughts are packages of energy and therefore waves and particles Neuronal transmission to thoughts is well within the purview of science, not outside Comment from : @jerrymoffatt1530

Great talk, but amazing how brains short circuit and drag gods in to the equation Comment from : @sokklei

I think AI will actually "save us" and bring us out of the dark ages This is because AI will clarify for everyone that consciousness is not equivalent to intelligence AI will show that knowledge is entirely subjective and not an end in itself AI will show that information is cheap and meaningless AI will usher in a new age The age of information will die, and we will have a rebirth in discovering meaning Comment from : @aisthpaoitht

Riveting & delightful !If only we could hear Richard Holloway (previously Archbishop of Edinburgh) and Ian sharing ideas and conundrums ! Comment from : @williamhuband7913

Another attempt bye religion to bring their voo doo into science, Again failed brTo bring onto table you have actually bring god onto the table, where was god in this video , nothing but assertionsbrPlease leave god to the ignorant and superstitious and leave science to those who are still based in reality Comment from : @ossiedunstan4419

The Jewish cabbalah is a heterodox endeavor McGilchrist makes explicitly use of occultist symbols like the beast biting it's own tail Comment from : @piushalg5041

McGilchrist has clearly gnostic views, for exemple he thinks obviously that creative human beings help God to become more perfect in some way This is not orthodox Christianity God does not need any help And he is not altering in any way Comment from : @piushalg5041

This is ImportantbrNo God No Religion This is TRUTH 💗👍🌞🌅 Comment from : @venkateshprabhu7027

Wonderful, wonderful conversation! Regarding the problem of evil (the Holocaust), the best response is David Bentley Hart's book Doors to the Sea A short, brilliant response Comment from : @FredvonHayek

I am seeing a trend here amoung the academics The atheist scientist put their faith in theories, hypothesis, and speculation The God believers ultimately put their fait in God for everything known and unknown brIronic the lay person atheist and God Believers are the same regardless of intelligence or knowledge brIm seeing little value to such debates because i do not see where it changes the hearts and minds of anyone I think it is more of an affirmation session for atheist and God Believers alikebrThat is my hypothesis and Im sticking to it Comment from : @jaybailleaux630

as usual they presupposes god Comment from : @matswessling6600

How can so intelligent people have such wrong ideas about nature With all my respect, I think when both of you would study some physics, you would realize that your actual vision is wrong and non-scientific One of the big problems nowadays is that many intelligent people, knowing how to express themselves very well, can be so un-scientific due to a lack of deep knowledge in physics and molecular biology Please follow some lectures of Sean CarrollbrAfter listening to the complete discussion I have to conclude that lady Sharon even did not study deeply what religion is Please update yourself with the history of how religion came about and you will notice as an objective scientist that all is based on stories and fairy tails Comment from : @gilbertengler9064

As a collective phenomenon, religion is close to art Both activities aim for experientiality Science does not aim for this The possible experience is a by-product, even experienced by fewbrPsychological studies have long evoked negative or repulsive experiences, and their progress is therefore laborious Comment from : @eensio

Another trinity to consider: left-brain, right-brain, heart-mind (or 'shen' in Chinese) Comment from : @grahambates7162

This is not enlightening, the idea that everything is conscious explains everything and nothing Comment from : @johnbarryyallagher1128

Science and god do not mix, god is supernatural science has no observations of the supernatural outside the claims of people of ignorance and superstition Comment from : @ossiedunstan4419

God only exists in peoples minds mainly due to the brainwashing of the very young! Comment from : @James-sj7pl

That was SOOOO much fun, and so satisfying! Thank you!!!! Comment from : @danatowne5498

Where is the survey? Comment from : @dapaulson1

When I get up in the morning for breakfast, is it my brain that decides whether I will choose a peanut butter sandwich or ham and eggs or is there a “me” who makes that choice? Naturalism has reduced us to a dualism…attempting to explain everything with the amazing but limited tools of science Comment from : @dapaulson1

Profoundly moved I love having my prejudices ripped apart! Comment from : @dapaulson1

There is no free will according to Einstein, Hawking, etc Particles obey the laws of physics They go to their next location based on the laws of physics A wave in the ocean splashing against the shore does not decide how to splash Same thing for us The particles go to the next spot and that becomes the next thought No one is making decisions because they are determined by the particle movement We have to decide what we are going to decide No conclusions, no objective observation, etc Look it up The logic problem is that you can't have science without these things; science requires decisions, conclusions, objective observationbrWithout a soul, a spirit, something beyond the particles there can be no science This is not word trickery, it is the facts of the case brbrBible, RomansbrbrFor since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excusebrbrbrLast thoughts, do we want our sin or to we want God? brbrbrBible, Hebrewsbrbrwithout faith it is impossible to please God Comment from : @davantstewart2285

This is a pre-ChatGPT talk Comment from : @hoppechr

The quale exactly results from the bidentity/b of mind and information processing states in the experiencer‘s brain which is inaccessible to any other person A consciousness per se by it‘s very nature could never be unconscious or suffer from impaired consciousness But we actually may suffer from loss or impairment of consciousness Thus, our human consciousness is not substantial or brain-independent Comment from : @hoppechr

I think a bit of Sartre would be in order for these panelists, especially Dr Dirkcx As neuroscience progresses, we'll most assuredly find the specific source of "God" in the human mind It is inconceivable that God - whom the panelists define in quite different ways - existed in a vacuum, as Dirckx suggests, and decided on a whim one fine day, to create Heaven and earth As for Dr McGilchrist, to say, as he does, that God is a force is to say nothing at all To say, as he also says, that God is in everything and that everything is in God is meaningless as well There are indeed forces that bring things together and rend things apart They are electromagnetism, gravity and the like They are not God Where Dr, McGilchrist is absolutely right is in his assertion that the Christian God is the "apotheosis of the left hemisphere" Which is nothing more and nothing less than an assertion that God is a creation of the human mind Comment from : @cavaradossi7761

McGilchrist couldn't even begin to explain what a 'right hemisphere' society would look like today, he is no different than Marxists screaming for a utopia Comment from : @Bob-qq4is

why is this dudes glasses so far down his face Comment from : @Bob-qq4is

Please brSharebr70 AD in Jerusalem brWhat He Shouted To All brWhy They Tried To Stone Him To Death For Healing Someone In The Temple That Same Day On A SABBATH!brHe Left To Begin His Church 🕊❤️🙏🏻🎉 Comment from : @jillphilips3788

Please brShare brGod Said Askbr1 John 5:14-15brJohn 14:14brJohn 15:6-8brJohn 16:23brLuke 1:37br🕊❤️🙏🏻🎉 Comment from : @jillphilips3788

Please brSharebrAll of YoubrNever Touched OnbrAll Thoughts ofbrWhat Is All Facts OnbrFemales brAnd MalesbrBoth Have Two Hemispheres!brAll Much Is Never Spoken ENOUGH ON Our Gift Of The Holy Spirit Given brUnto Those Who Ask in Our HeartsbrIn Our Bible It Presents the Devil Can Not be Saved because He Has No Soul Just A Evil Spirit Self as a godbrNo FALSE MARKETINGbr🕊❤️🙏🏻🎉 Comment from : @jillphilips3788

Please brSharebrYes Share brGod Is Our Creator brPsalms 33:12brProverbs 3:5-6br1 Thessalonians 5:21brProverbs 16:18brPhilippians 3:8-9brHis Righteousness’s brNo False Marketing “brHe Shouted TO ALL IN 70 AD In Jerusalem 🕊❤️🙏🏻brAnd HE SHOUTED LOUDLY TOO “ No MORE FALSE RELIGIOUS TEACHERS WHO DO NOT PRACTICE WHAT THEY PREACHbrHis Righteousness’s Love Truths Discernment’s And Good Common Sense EACH NEW DAY NEVER THE LESSbr🕊❤️🙏🏻🎉 Comment from : @jillphilips3788

Please brSHAREbrONLY OUR CREATOR LORD GOD YESHUA CHRIST JESUS GAVE US BOTH HEMISPHERES! Comment from : @jillphilips3788

PLEASEbrSHAREbrSTART FIRST brWITH GLYPHOSATE ASBESTOSIS FLUORIDES PESTICIDES PRESERVATIVES METAL ALUMINUM LEAD MERCURY GMO RADIATION & PLASTICS & EUGENICSMANIPULATIONS!brFLUORIDE “ IS “ ALUMINUM “ brTHERE IS BABY POWDER Giving CANCER TO ALL and mouthwash toothpaste MANY MANY PRODUCTS brETC ETCbrJust Today only one place in the News Media” A product SOLD For EYE DROPS CAUSING DEATH!!!br“ NO MORE FALSE MARKETING brGod Bless YoubrHonor brRIGHTEOUSNESS brLove Truths Discernment’s And Good Common Sense brEACH NEW DAY NEVER THE LESS br🕊❤️🙏🏻🎉 Comment from : @jillphilips3788

Take A Moment brThe Wizard of Sillynsss brRelax brMy fellow Ape man/womanbrThe Rocky paths are longbrStillbrAways look on the bright side of life brStay Safe and Stay Free Comment from : @jestermoon

Noice Comment from : @xotube2206

This is one of the best videos I have watched It touches on most --- but not not all ---- of 90 years of experiences ---- that I am trying yo record in a book strictly for the medical profession ---- for which I may have another 30 years ---- minutes --- hours ---- days --- to complete Half a story makes no sense Mine has a beginning, a development ----- but so far no conclusion --- so- it is like a novel that has lost its last chapter brbrI think it is worth trying to write because, as a qualified therapist (Oxford 1957) it might help other people I am a novice re computer science ---- so i will need a lot of practical helpbrbrMy sister is left-handed and never really recovered from the ways she was treated at school I am ambidextrous and have no sense of Left and Right apart from using a violin with my left hand ---- but a strong sense of North -- South --- East --- West ----- so long as I am facing the mid-day sun ----- which was different in Zimbabwe ---- or was it? Can't remember I have recovered from a few strokes (left side) --- melborp rorrim gnitiirw --- well --- mirror writing doesn't work here ---- also Goldsmith College Art school in London ----br brThe October Synod in Rome 2014 brbrOh come and join the catholic Church, now we’ve completed our research bron how to run our Kingdom's rules and what to teach in all our schools brNow no anointed King need rule, as all the pupils in the school brenjoy equality with Him, with Cherubim and Seraphim br brNo hierarchy need you fear, as all the Bishops gathered here brhave equal rights to have their say, to tell you whom you must obey brCommittees now are all we need to sort the problems of our Creed brAll Dogmas that offend your ear can now be made to disappear br brNor need you ever doctrines hear, nor false opinions need for-swear, bras all depends what you believe, as anything they preconceive brhas all evolved from man-made laws, which change with time and man's applause brWith ten Commandments out of date, we're free to new ones innovate br brSubjective feelings over-rule objective Truth We ridicule br the Fathers of the ancient Church; rely upon our own research brOh come and join the free-for-all that Adam chose, when, at the Fall, brhistorically, he lost the plot and thought that God could be forgot Comment from : @jy7383

Whats the role of the lady in this debate!!? Comment from : @AliAbidalkareem

I could not digest the idea of mixing neuroscience and theology and faith in this event Science and religious faith can never meet and neither of the two can ever prove of disprove the existence of an intelligent eternal creator or intelligent designer The respectable lady was insisting on applying christian faith to science and she obviously failed miserably Comment from : @abduladheemal-tamimi2371

Sharon's view of God is dogmatic: putting God separate from the individual Yet, the very Christian bible, says, "God is your life" and "you are dead and your life is hid with Christ in God" Christ as one that existed, died and rose again and will come back, does not make life worth living in the present!brbrIain's view is closer to reality Otherwise, the content of Revelation 4:11 makes God a sadist; one that wants to enjoy creation as the created suffer! Comment from : @Jagombe1

what a unrefined and un-nuanced interviewer for this wonderful talk Comment from : @naturelover1284

I joke that I want to be in charge of housing in the next life I'll put a militant fundamentalist in a room with a militant atheist and let them come out when they've come to a synthesis, or in 10,000 years, whichever comes later 😀 Yet Jesus chose both Matthew and Simon My song "We Need Each Other" says, br"Sometimes when we argue, brA grain of truth is sown brIf we humbly nurture it, brWe'll bring a harvest home brThru respect and listening, brWe finally agree, brAnd form a stronger partnership brThan one found easily" Comment from : @daneumurian5466

Someone should demonstrate the existence of consciousness without neurons and a brain or something very simular brI'm going to just go ahead and say that what we describe as 'consciousness" is nothing more than our Perception of what is actually taking place when a particular area of the brain is stimulated and an organized bioelectrical/chemical reaction takes place between neurons in which this gives rise to a "thought" or emotion or sensory input of information Our DNA can be considered as an Operating system and hardware recognition interface, our brains as the central processor and our senses as Input/Output interfacebrI can't possibly believe that a 'god" created something this simpple and yet so infinitely complexbrConsider the number of organisms that exist on this planet and that humans make up only 01 of that total This number btw doesn't account for single cell organisms and the variety that exists there brRoll a die enough times and at some point it WILL at some point stop on a corner instead of on one of it's facesbrOur mind and consciousness is a product of all these things , and more, but it was not a "created" thing by some Diety or Supernatural being Comment from : @michaeljames1056

Everything is a miracle You have to jump, before you know you can fly Comment from : @davetaylor5677

If a very large asteroid was on track to smash into the earth, the kind of thinking that Gilchrist seems to disdain is just what will save us Not EQ, ‘imagination’ & ‘seeing reality’ in the manner of Wordsworth & Coleridge If Gilchrist ever required advanced medical treatment I’m sure he’d instantly begin to appreciate the categorising kind of thinking The universe is a dangerous place & if we are to survive, we need to put our left hemispheres to work Comment from : @carvakasatyasrutah9249

What an interesting argument for something that has absolutely no evidence of actual existence, which is why people work, and have these different radical and odd beliefs about some thing brbrIt’s a wishful thought not a reality As I always say there’s 000000 evidence of god, but there 100 evidence of people who cause harm to others despite their imaginary friend supposedly based and created out of love Comment from : @seihomorris4994

History will loo, back on our time and call us backward dunces: Comment from : @fritula6200

His thoughts give too much comfort to those who are looking for a prop from normal religion Comment from : @danremenyi1179

Iain view of the God of Christianity proves that He is the real God How? By the fact that a God who allows evil to happen BECAUSE He allows his creation the free will which due to sin they use and abuse, is unconceivable by human mind and thinking The fact that Jesus is the ONLY God who died for His creation to pay the penalty for their sin, the consequences of their free will despite His given conscience which He put in each human, is unacceptable and unconceivable by human mind The fact that Jesus, the God of Christianity is love and died for his bitter enemies, the human race, His own creation just to restore the relationship again with them and give them eternal life with Him, this didn't come from the invention of man or philosophers but from the mind and heart of God All these are contrary to sinful human reasoning but it makes so much sense to those who humble themselves to accept that they are limited, created beings and cry out to their Creator, Jesus brI pray that such brilliant gifted by God people like Iain and many more will continue to humble themselves and seek for the truth They will find out, if they are honest that truth is a person, the God Jesus, that peace and enlightenment is a person, Jesus "And you shall seek me, and find me, when you shall seek me with ALL your heart, and the truth will set you free I Jesus am the way, the truth and the light and no one can reach to the true God, the Father, but by/thru Me" See in the Bible Jeremiah chapter 29 verse 13, 29:13/ John chaper 8 verses 32 & 36/ John chapter 14 verse 6 Will pray for Iain soul salvation to be truly enlightened and find the truth and peace Comment from : @gabrielanita8319

How can anyone be a militant atheist? Comment from : @plasticvision6355

Completely and totally fascinating Sharon was remarkable presenting situations that needed a response from an extremely intelligent man Comment from : @tonysullivan1603

The discussion went approximately OK until it deviated into the religious BS Comment from : @mikel4879

We are not the only conscious beings, all animals, esp mammals are conscious beings, evolution explains it all All religions are total BS, just ancient stories invented by charlatans for power and profit, giving false explanations for things they knew nothing about Ezra invented all Western Religions when he and his scribes invented Adam, Eve, Abraham, Moses in creating the first five books of the Torah/ OT Comment from : @user-nj2ru1ov8i

Fascism is entirely Right Wing, never Left I think he should study politics and not comment on things he doesn't understand Comment from : @user-nj2ru1ov8i

Wetness is an emergent property of water Two gases combine to make a wet substance Comment from : @user-nj2ru1ov8i

Rationally: The best explanation for consciousness is that it is an Emergent Property of the Physical Brain There is absolutely no valid evidence for any other explanation Consciousness arose from our physical evolution from Cell, Fish, Lizard, Mamal to our final form Theology is only the study of Make-Believe Comment from : @user-nj2ru1ov8i

A Theophany is very much not the same as panentheism, for the latter violates the creator creature distinctions and makes no essence/energy distinctionsbrHowever, I can understand why he makes that error and that Western Christianity has totally lost this concept is among the reasons it led to atheism Comment from : @somechristianguy5810

Insightful Comment from : @vijay-1

Related Iain McGilchrist u0026 Sharon Dirckx • Brain science, consciousness u0026 God videos

Attention as a moral Act: Iain McGilchrist u0026 Jonathan Rowson in Conversation РѕС‚ : PERSPECTIVA Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

The Attack On Life and Understanding Our Times. A conversation with Iain McGilchrist and Mark Vernon РѕС‚ : Dr Iain McGilchrist Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Michael Shermer with Philip Goff — Galileo’s Error: Foundations for a New Science of Consciousness РѕС‚ : Skeptic Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

The Psychology of Career Decisions | Sharon Belden Castonguay | TEDxWesleyanU РѕС‚ : TEDx Talks Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

GOD IS TELLING YOU TO STOP WORRYING u0026 START TRUSTING | Give It To God - Inspirational u0026 Motivational РѕС‚ : ABOVE INSPIRATION Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

HIDDEN TEACHINGS of the Bible That Explain Manifestation, Consciousness u0026 Oneness (POWERFUL Info!) РѕС‚ : Your Youniverse Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Data Science Full Course - Learn Data Science in 10 Hours | Data Science For Beginners | Edureka РѕС‚ : edureka! Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

TRUST GOD IS WORKING | God Has Not Forgotten You - Inspirational u0026 Motivational Video РѕС‚ : ABOVE INSPIRATION Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

GOD’S TESTING | Trust God Through The Trial - Inspirational u0026 Motivational Video РѕС‚ : ABOVE INSPIRATION Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time

Complete Restoration | Body, Mind and Spirit Healing | Raise your Consciousness РѕС‚ : Relaxed Mind Download Full Episodes | The Most Watched videos of all time